Thanks for all the info, guys!

Apparently the rotors are the same for all Valkyrie models, they just differ by the year.
97/98 models have a J1 rotor which has the screws sticking out a bit.
99 and newer models have a J2 rotor and the screws are recessed.
I will have a used one sent to me tomorrow. It still has a thickness of 7.3mm (brand new is 7.5mm).
I will put this one on and then take care of the one I messed up and see how bad it is.
Thanks for all the info and help, very much appreciated!!!!