MN,
You need to look at both the spline that attaches to the wheel side (with the 5 'pins'), and the hub splines...
I could see that my wheel side splines were worn down, but once I looked at my hub side, where the splines mate, I knew there was no question I needed to replace both parts.
Here is a pic of my old splines... Notice how the teeth seem to be worn down and 'pointed'?

Now, here is a pic of the hub I got through Pinwall... Notice how nice and 'square' the teeth are?

The wheel side splines looked just as bad... Those I ordered new from HDL, for about $120.
Hope this helps.
Black Dog