James, I'm sure the Naples area is more populated now. It more than likely has more tourists now than locals when you came down to go fishing.
It's hard to get farther south without getting your feet wet,

and yes it is a little warmer DOWN HERE.
I'm not familiar with the Venice area or Snook Haven, but I'd sure like to do a meet and greet and check it out if we can set a date that fits folks schedules.
Troyers Dutch Heritage Restaurant is a buffet in Sarasota. The VTX group I ride with on occasion has had meet and greets there. The staff was very accommodating when we called and told them we'd have 30 people showing up for lunch. Keep that place in mind if you all are OK with a place that doesn't serve beer.