The battery is now at 11.84 v. Still hooked up to the trickle charger. Still just clicks when I hit the starter button.
Just went out and hooked it up to my big battery charger, set it to start and it started right up. Yesterday when I tried this I had it hooked up wrong (on charge mode, not start mode).

Duh, oh well. Thanks for the help comment.

The battery is less than 1 year old so I'm hoping it will still be good but it's not OEM so who knows. Usually you get what you pay for.