I would suggest considering the following.
You may want to stay with a Motorcycle tire if;
- you ride less than 6 thousand miles a year.
+average life of a M/C tire is about 6k thus 1 new tire a year.
- you don't like to spend $200+ on one tire.
You may want to Darkside if;
- you ride more than 6k a year.
+average life of a D/S tire is about 16k (have seen reports over 20K).
- you want to spend less on a tire
+you can spend anywhere from $60-$170 and get great D/S tires.
- you tow a trailer.
+ delamination of M/C tires have been reported when towing trailers.
I ride a lot. Replacing an expensive M/C tire 2-3 times a year was out of the question. I first rode a Good Year Triple Tread, and though I got 17k out of it I didn't like it's handling. I now ride a Vredestein Sportrac 3. Phenomenal handling tire, but you can't buy them anymore. You can't go wrong with the Austone Taxi Tire (you can only get them here
https://www.universaltire.com/175r16-austone-taxi-black.html).
My Ups ++++
+ Life of the tire

+ Safely plugging a puncture

+ My wife prefers the ride on the back seat with the D/S tire

+ Wet and gravel rode traction is excellent

+ Rear braking is hugely improved

My downs ----
- have gotten harassed on the road

- have gotten harassed here on the VRCC

- finding a tire shop to mount the tire
Hope this helps you make an informed decision. Let us know what you end up doing.