When I pulled the tank I was getting fuel leaking on my hand as I manipulated the valve while removing the chrome selector.
Fuel leaking from
where on the valve? A bad diaphragm would have it leaking from the weep hole and/or outlet nipple if the valve isn't in the OFF position. If only a small amount of fuel leaked (a few drips), it could just be residual fuel in the vacuum side of the valve, and not an issue at all. Did you notice any leaking fuel before you started to pull the tank? If not, it would be highly coincidental for a seal to start leaking as you were pulling the tank.