sorry to be the bearer of bad news but the 76 house in Tappan NY is way earlier
The Old '76 House (also just called '76 House) is a true American Classic. Built in 1686 when the Dutch founded Tappan, it's been a public house ever since. During the revolutionary war--because of Tappan's proximity to the lines of battle--the tavern became an important center for activity.
It is where Major Andre was held before being hung at the order of Gen Washington for having received the plans for West Point from Benedict Arnold
I drive by it every week on the way to visit my mom
The '76 House, also known as the Old '76 House, is a Colonial-era structure built as a home and tavern in Tappan, New York, in 1754 by Casparus Mabie, a merchant and tavern-keeper.
History
Origin
In spite of local claims of much earlier construction (dating to founding of Tappan in 1686), the '76 House appears only to predate the American Revolution by several decades. The earliest confirmed dates concerning any structure on or near the site involve one Antie Myers, a widow, who was licensed in 1705 to sell drink, "as per her recognizance," in her house in the immediate neighborhood of today's '76 House.[citation needed] After her death around 1721 her home was purchased by Yoast Mabie, a brother of Casparus. The house was demolished in 1835. In 1753, Casparus Mabie bought a piece of land from Cornelis Myers, Antie's son.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_'76_House