While I've never considered anything other than our older Valks, I'm still a manual shift kind of guy.   But, I've never ridden a bike with an automatic transmission so on that, I'm simply not qualified to make such a judgement.
The fact that it's offered on a Honda makes me feel more confident about such a choice.   Honda has always been about quality and reliability in my opinion.  I sincerely believe in the KISS method of vehicles.  (Keep It Simple Stupid) The more options added simply increase the things that can go wrong.   Would I be willing to try one?   Probably if the right situation presented itself but, I simply don't see me out living my current Valkyries.   This assumes no more (survivable) crashes.  

Rams