I guess everyone has their own experience... I've had mine since the first InZane in Paducah KY, and not only use them for riding, but for fishing too.
I got the style with the 'bib' pants, and short jacket, in a size appropriate for my big 270lb azz. It took me no time at all to add the leg protection (my wife did it

). Ugly? Yeppers. Do they billow up at times? Yes again. Do they keep me dry? Hell yes, and that is why I got them.
Case in point... Last year, on the way to meet Timbr, Chilli, RTaz, and the rest of the goof balls, from Michigan, I started from my house in the rain... Hard rain. The kinda storm ya see on the cover of one of Daniel Meyers books

. I rode for over 200 miles in some of the worst rain I've ever ridden in... When the sun finally came out, the only part of me that was wet, were the cuffs of my jeans, and a small bit of my neck.
Treat 'em right, don't expect them to hold up to a bar brawl, and for $45 ya can't go wrong.
Just my .02

Black Dog