Head down to your local NAPA store or to Collinite's website and get yourself some "Metal Wax". Then, get a tin of Mother's Carnauba Wax and an empty wax tin. Mix half the Collinite with half of the Mother's in the empty tin and set aside.
Next, work on your wheels with progressively finer grits of emery and crocus cloth. I used plain ol' water to keep my abrasives from loading up when doing the '01 I/S's wheels. Started with 150, then 220...600, 1000 and lastly 1500 grit.
When they were smooth but not shiny I took the Metal Wax/Mother's combo to them. The stuff cuts like Hagerty's Metal Polish but IMO shines the wheels a bit more. This is a case where the sum is definitely greater than the parts, as the wheels come out looking almost like chrome - even with a hand application of the compound - and one treatment lasts several months.
I used to call the blend "Peer Pressure In A Can". That is, when I did a little spot on someone's dirty, neglected rims they felt 'obligated' to finish the job lest they get a good heckling.
